← Public evidence ledger
RedState
Article misinformation risk ★★★★★ ★★★★★ 0.5/5 Mostly accurate · 2 checked claims

Feel the Warmth of Collectivism: Mamdani Gets Flame-Broiled for His Heat Wave Advice

RedState criticizes New York City Mayor Zohran Kwame Mamdani for urging residents during a record heat wave to set air conditioners to 78°F, turn off/unplug lights and electronics, and saying the city would maintain a 78-degree rule and dim/turn off lights in city buildings. The article also states forecasts of 100°F+ highs and heat indices of 110–115°F.

Open the original RedState article ↗

Mostly accurate
Public importance 70/100

“New York City Mayor Zohran Kwame Mamdani posted on X urging New Yorkers to set their air conditioners to 78 degrees, turn off lights/electronics they are not using, unplug what they can, and said the city would maintain a 78-degree rule in city buildings, dim/turn off lights during peak demand, ask private partners to do the same, and power down non-essential equipment.”

Attributed to RedState (quoting Zohran Kwame Mamdani)

✓ Proof standard met 3 reachable references Independent-source requirement passed
Original context and attribution

Article quotes Mamdani's post on X during a heat wave advising residents to set AC to 78°F and describing city measures including a 78-degree rule in municipal buildings, dimming/turning off lights, asking private partners to reduce usage, and powering down non-essential equipment.

What the proof shows

Primary official sources and contemporaneous reporting show Mayor Zohran Mamdani did post on X and the City issued guidance asking New Yorkers and businesses to set thermostats to 78°F, turn off unused lights/electronics, and conserve energy; the City’s July 1, 2026 press release explicitly asks businesses to set thermostats to 78°F and says the City asked private partners (e.g., Times Square sign operators) to reduce brightness. However, the announcements were framed as requests and emergency measures (not a blanket criminal mandate on private residences), and reporting (New York Post inspection) found many municipal spaces were below 78°F, so the claim that the City was uniformly “maintaining the 78-degree rule in our buildings” is overstated as an implemented, citywide reality. The overall factual elements quoted by RedState (the X post wording and the City measures) are supported by official releases and multiple news outlets, but important context about the voluntary/request nature and uneven implementation is missing.

Corrected version

Mayor Zohran Mamdani posted on X urging New Yorkers to conserve energy — e.g., “set your AC to 78 degrees, turn off lights/electronics you’re not using, and unplug what you can” — and the City’s July 1, 2026 press release asked businesses to set thermostats to 78°F, encouraged New Yorkers to avoid running major appliances during peak hours, and sought reductions in lighting/brightness from private partners. These were presented as requests and emergency actions; local reporting found municipal buildings were not uniformly at 78°F.

Automated evidence confidence: 0%

References and proof

Every link was reachable when published. Each proof point states how that source bears on the claim.

Official data Supports

Mayor Mamdani Expands Emergency Heat Measures to Protect New Yorkers During Historic Holiday Weekend Heat Wave ↗

Office of the Mayor, City of New York
Proof point

Asking all businesses to set thermostats to 78 degrees and encouraging all New Yorkers to conserve energy during peak demand. The City is asking every business and every New Yorker to do their part in protecting energy grid reliability by setting their thermostats to 78 degrees and holding off on running major appliances until early morning or late at night. The City has also worked with the Times Square Alliance to request sign operators to lower energy consumption by reducing brightness.

Independent reporting Supports

NYC mayor Zohran Mamdani asks residents to 'set AC to 78 degrees' amid heat wave; MAGA says, 'This is what socialism looks like' ↗

Times of India (news reporting quoting Mamdani's X post)
Proof point

“New York: it's hot out there, and the power grid is working overtime to keep us cool. Set your AC to 78 degrees, turn off lights/electronics you're not using, and unplug what you can. Our City is doing its part too: maintaining the 78 degrees rule in our buildings, dimming/turning off our lights during peak electricity demand, asking private partners to do the same, and powering down non-essential equipment,” he wrote on X on July 1, 2026.

Independent reporting Contradicts

Mamdani can’t even get City Hall to stick to his 78-degree AC rule — as temps in building hit as low as 54 ↗

New York Post
Proof point

Temperatures inside City Hall plunged as low as 54 degrees Thursday during the ongoing heat wave — despite Mayor Zohran Mamdani urging New Yorkers to set their air conditioners to a balmy 78... Post reporters tested 20 spots within City Hall and other municipal offices — and all but five of them were below 78 degrees.

Mostly accurate
Public importance 70/100

“New York City is enduring a historic and dangerous heat wave with temperatures forecast to reach 100 degrees Fahrenheit or higher on Thursday and Friday and heat indices expected to climb to 110–115 degrees due to high humidity.”

Attributed to RedState (article)

✓ Proof standard met 5 reachable references Independent-source requirement passed
Original context and attribution

The article states that NYC is facing a historic, dangerous heat wave and provides specific temperature and heat-index forecast figures for upcoming days.

What the proof shows

Official forecasts and city statements confirm New York City faced a dangerous, multi-day heat wave with highs around 95–100°F (Central Park reached ~100°F on July 2) and heat indices in the triple digits. The National Weather Service and the City called extreme/dangerous heat and opened cooling centers. However, the NWS products for NYC specifically forecast heat-index values mostly in the 105–110°F range (with some language allowing ‘a little higher’ or isolated hotter spots). Independent outlets and some regional forecasts described localized feels-like values up to 110–115°F across parts of the mid‑Atlantic — so saying 110–115°F is plausible for nearby/localized spots but slightly exaggerates the official central NYC NWS forecast (105–110°F).

Corrected version

New York City is experiencing a dangerous, historic heat wave with highs around 95–100°F (Central Park reached about 100°F on July 2) and heat‑index (feels‑like) values generally forecast around 105–110°F across the city, with isolated spots in the region possibly reaching 110–115°F.

Automated evidence confidence: 0%

References and proof

Every link was reachable when published. Each proof point states how that source bears on the claim.

Official data Supports

Extreme Heat Warning ↗

National Weather Service New York NY (forecast.weather.gov)
Proof point

"...Dangerously hot conditions with heat index values of 105 to 110."

Official data Contradicts

Area Forecast Discussion ↗

National Weather Service New York NY - Area Forecast Discussion
Proof point

"high temps 95-100 combined with dewpoints in the lower 70s could still result in heat index values of 105 or a little higher."

Official data Supports

Mayor Mamdani Expands Emergency Heat Measures to Protect New Yorkers During Historic Holiday Weekend Heat Wave ↗

NYC Mayor's Office
Proof point

"historic... heat wave"; City converting additional locations to cooling centers; "Triple‑digit heat index values are expected to persist through Saturday, July 4."

Independent reporting Supports

Extreme heat warning issued for NYC area as feels-like temps could hit 115 | FOX 5 New York ↗

FOX 5 New York
Proof point

"Highs in New York City could reach around 100 degrees Thursday and Friday... heat index values are expected to skyrocket to 110–115 degrees."

Independent reporting Supports

Heat wave starts in NYC and N.J. Here's the weather forecast. ↗

CBS New York
Proof point

The National Weather Service has issued an Extreme Heat Warning... With the hazy, hot and humid conditions, it will feel like 105 to 110 degrees Thursday. "If it reaches 100 in Central Park, it would be the first time New York City officially hits the century mark since July 18, 2012."

COMMUNITY EVIDENCE

Discussion

Disagreement is welcome. Spam and abuse are not.

No published comments yet. Add evidence or challenge the reasoning.

Members can comment for free

Create a free membership or sign in.