Article misinformation risk★★☆☆☆2.2/5
Use caution · 3 checked claims
sitemap
Israel Eases Bans On Gaza
The New York Post reports that Israel began allowing long-banned building materials into the Gaza Strip as a first concession under a cease-fire, and that the military said shipments will continue and the five-year blockade could be eased further if the border stays quiet. The piece notes Hamas called shipments "cosmetic" and recalls Israel's embargo after Hamas took control in 2007 and a 2010 partial easing.
“Israel has started allowing long-banned building materials into the Gaza Strip.”
Attributed to Israeli military spokesman Maj. Guy Inbar (reported by New York Post)
✓ Proof standard met4 reachable referencesIndependent-source requirement passed
Original context and attribution
Article states the military said this was the first key concession to Hamas rulers under a cease-fire that ended eight days of fighting.
What the proof shows
Contemporaneous official and reporting sources confirm that in late December 2012 Israel began allowing limited shipments of construction materials (e.g., gravel, aggregates and later specific shipments of cement/steel under controls) into Gaza — a change the Israeli military described as a concession under the November 2012 cease-fire. However, the change was narrow and controlled (initially ~20 truckloads/day and limited items/uses), and basic construction materials had already been allowed into Gaza for internationally supervised projects since 2010. The New York Post wording is correct that materials were allowed after being long restricted, but it omits key limits (small volumes, monitoring, and continuing controls on many “dual‑use” items), so the overall impression is missing important context.
Corrected version
In late December 2012 Israel began allowing limited shipments of previously restricted construction materials into Gaza (initially around 20 truckloads a day), as a cease-fire concession; the flows were small, strictly controlled, and many dual‑use items remained restricted or subject to approval.
Automated evidence confidence: 0%
References and proof
Every link was reachable when published. Each proof point states how that source bears on the claim.
UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA)
Proof point
In late December 2012, as part of the ceasefire understanding with Hamas, Israel began ... allowing import of basic construction materials ... although the volume allowed so far is extremely small compared to the existing demand.
Israel has started allowing long-banned building materials into the Gaza Strip ... 'Now we're talking about a permanent easing,' said military spokesman Maj. Guy Inbar. He said 20 truckloads a day could enter Gaza.
OCHA data show tens of thousands of truckloads of construction material have crossed from Israel to Gaza since June 2010; the recent measure applied to private‑sector gravel shipments and built on prior, limited allowances for internationally supervised projects.
Missing important context
Public importance 70/100
“Shipments of building materials will continue and Israel's five-year blockade of Gaza may be eased further if the border remains quiet.”
Attributed to Israeli military spokesman Maj. Guy Inbar (reported by New York Post)
✓ Proof standard met4 reachable referencesIndependent-source requirement passed
Original context and attribution
The military spokesman is quoted offering continued shipments and possible additional easings conditional on continued calm at the border.
What the proof shows
The New York Post attribution to Israeli military spokesman Maj. Guy Inbar is accurate: Israeli officials announced limited shipments (e.g., 20 truckloads of gravel per day) and Inbar said further easing would be considered "as long as quiet is maintained." However the claim omits important context: (1) the 2007 blockade remained in place and many construction items were still restricted under COGAT’s ‘dual-use’/restricted import lists, and (2) Israel had already been allowing construction materials into Gaza for internationally supervised projects (humanitarian/UN projects), so this was a limited policy change for the private sector rather than a removal of the blockade. Those omissions make the Post’s overall impression — that the blockade was being meaningfully lifted — misleading without qualification.
Corrected version
Israeli officials said they would permit limited shipments of certain building materials (initially about 20 truckloads of gravel per day for private construction) and that they might consider further, security‑conditioned easings of some restrictions if the border remains quiet; however the 2007 blockade and COGAT restrictions on many construction items remained in force and larger-scale imports continued largely through approved international projects and special approval processes.
Automated evidence confidence: 0%
References and proof
Every link was reachable when published. Each proof point states how that source bears on the claim.
Under the new arrangements, 20 lorries a day carrying gravel and other building materials will cross into Gaza, five days a week. 'The longer the calm persists, the more we’ll weigh additional easing of restrictions that will benefit the private sector,' Maj Guy Inbar said.
UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA)
Proof point
In June 2007, following the takeover of Gaza by Hamas, Israel imposed a land, sea and air blockade on the Gaza Strip.... The Israeli authorities have recently eased some of these restrictions, but the basic constraints remain in place, preventing a significant improvement in the economy.
Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) / UN report
Proof point
COGAT, Restricted Import List Gaza Strip, 2013... Dual use is defined as 'civilian goods that can be utilised in military situations.' Those that are allowed require intensive prior coordination... (mentions cement, steel bars as restricted/controlled).
According to the United Nation’s Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA), since June 2010, 40,041 truckloads of building goods entered the Gaza Strip from Israel, earmarked for construction projects sponsored by international aid groups.
Mostly accurate
Public importance 70/100
“Israel imposed a land and naval embargo on Gaza after Hamas took over by force in 2007; although it eased the land embargo in 2010, building materials continued to be largely banned.”
Attributed to New York Post (reporting established background)
✓ Proof standard met5 reachable referencesIndependent-source requirement passed
Original context and attribution
The article provides this historical background to explain the significance of the new allowance of building materials.
What the proof shows
Authoritative UN and NGO records show that after Hamas’s violent takeover of Gaza in June 2007 Israel significantly tightened movement and trade controls (land, air and sea) and maintained a naval cordon. Israel announced a package of easings in June 2010 that expanded the range of consumer goods allowed through land crossings, but multiple UN and humanitarian reports and rights groups record that imports of basic construction materials (cement, steel bars, aggregates, concrete blocks, asphalt, etc.) remained tightly restricted — typically allowed only in limited quantities and mostly for pre‑approved projects under international supervision. Thus the New York Post’s overall impression is supported, though it omits the qualification that some construction materials were allowed in limited, supervised circumstances after 2010 rather than being categorically banned. Evidence cited below documents both the 2007 tightening (land + naval) and the June 2010 easing plus continued restrictions on building materials.
Corrected version
After Hamas seized control of Gaza in June 2007, Israel imposed strict land and sea restrictions (including a naval cordon). In June 2010 Israel announced an easing that allowed many civilian goods through land crossings, but basic construction materials (cement, steel, aggregates and similar items) largely remained restricted and were typically permitted only in limited amounts for pre‑approved projects under international supervision.
Automated evidence confidence: 0%
References and proof
Every link was reachable when published. Each proof point states how that source bears on the claim.
United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA)
Proof point
In June 2010, following the ... flotilla’s attempt to break the blockade, Israel announced a package of measures to ease the access restrictions it had imposed on Gaza since June 2007. ... However, due to the pivotal nature of the remaining restrictions on the import of building materials, only a small minority of the 40,000 housing units ... could be actually constructed.
United Nations (Secretary‑General’s Panel of Inquiry)
Proof point
The restrictions imposed by Israel on goods entering Gaza by land, and the naval blockade over the waters off Gaza constitute a single 'blockade' ... The blockade has been continuously in force in fact at least since 2007...
United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA)
Proof point
Although the relaxation of the blockade has resulted in a greater variety of consumer goods, ongoing restrictions on basic construction materials, particularly cement, gravel and steel bars, continue to impede reconstruction. ... A limited amount of construction materials was allowed to enter for a number of pre‑approved humanitarian projects implemented by international organizations.
However, despite the easing of the blockade, crucial building materials continue to be restricted. ... Building materials such as steel and cement will only be allowed into Gaza under Israeli supervision and if they are to be used in projects overseen by the UN or other international agencies.
The Israeli Security Cabinet declared the easing of the Gaza blockade, particularly pertaining to civilian goods and humanitarian access. Construction materials will be allowed to enter only for projects under the supervision of the PA and International Organizations. ... The other list contains 19 types of construction materials, including cement, aggregates, concrete blocks, steel elements, asphalt...
COMMUNITY EVIDENCE
Discussion
Disagreement is welcome. Spam and abuse are not.
No published comments yet. Add evidence or challenge the reasoning.
Discussion
Disagreement is welcome. Spam and abuse are not.
No published comments yet. Add evidence or challenge the reasoning.
Members can comment for free
Create a free membership or sign in.