“U.S. AM/FM radio stations can broadcast commercial recordings without paying the recording artists or musicians who performed on them.”
Attributed to Lee Greenwood (Fox News opinion)
Greenwood argues that under current law AM/FM radio gets to play sound recordings and earn ad revenue while the performing artists and session musicians receive no payment.
What the proof shows
Under current U.S. federal copyright law, terrestrial (over‑the‑air) AM/FM radio stations are not required to pay performing artists or session musicians public‑performance royalties for the sound recordings they broadcast. Congress granted a limited public‑performance right in sound recordings only for digital audio transmissions (e.g., webcasters, satellite radio), not for traditional over‑the‑air broadcasts. This means songwriters/publishers receive performance payments via PROs (ASCAP/BMI/SESAC), while performers and master owners generally do not. The statement is accurate as a legal general rule but omits important context: digital/satellite/internet radio do pay performers under statutory licenses; some limited voluntary or negotiated arrangements and simulcast/digital transmissions are subject to payments; and Congress has repeatedly considered (but not enacted) legislation to change the rule.
Corrected version
More precisely: Under current U.S. federal law, terrestrial AM/FM radio stations generally may broadcast commercial sound recordings without paying performing artists or session musicians performance royalties for those over‑the‑air broadcasts; songwriters/publishers do receive performance royalties, and digital/satellite/internet radio services are required to pay performers and master owners under separate statutory regimes.
Automated evidence confidence: 0%
References and proof
Every link was reachable when published. Each proof point states how that source bears on the claim.
Digital Performance Right in Sound Recordings Act of 1995 ↗
U.S. Copyright Office / Public Law 104-39The 1995 Act grants copyright owners of sound recordings an exclusive right to perform their works 'by means of a digital audio transmission' — creating a limited public‑performance right for digital transmissions (not ordinary over‑the‑air broadcasts).
AM/FM Radio Royalty Loophole ↗
SoundExchange (performers' digital royalty organization)Because U.S. radio broadcasters refuse to pay artists when they use their recordings on the air, American artists and record labels are denied the estimated $200 million in performance royalties annually that would be paid to them in nearly every other nation.
Do Radio Stations Need Permission to Play Songs? ↗
LegalClarity (legal analysis)When your local FM station plays a hit song, the songwriter and publisher get paid through PROs; but the artist who actually performed the recording and the label receive nothing for that play under U.S. law (terrestrial radio).
ASCAP and the Radio Music License Committee Announce New Agreement ↗
ASCAP / Radio Music License Committee (press release)The agreement sets the rates payable by over 10,000 commercial terrestrial radio stations to publicly perform works in ASCAP’s repertory—showing that terrestrial radio pays songwriters/publishers via PRO licenses.
Federal Register: Digital Performance Right in Sound Recordings and Ephemeral Recordings (rules for §114 transmissions) ↗
U.S. Copyright Office / Federal RegisterEstablishes rates/terms for public performance of sound recordings in certain digital transmissions and defines 'Broadcast Simulcast' (simulcasts and other digital retransmissions are subject to section 114 performance royalties).
NAB: 'Congress should not impose any new performance fee' (industry position) ↗
National Association of BroadcastersCongress should not impose any new performance fee, tax, royalty, or other charge relating to the public performance of sound recordings on a local radio station for broadcasting sound recordings over‑the‑air.
Why Musicians Want Radio Stations to Start Paying Them ↗
Time (reporting)Performing artists currently don't get paid for traditional radio play, which has long been thought of as promotional rather than a direct revenue stream; bills such as the Performance Rights Act have been proposed to change that.
Discussion
Disagreement is welcome. Spam and abuse are not.
No published comments yet. Add evidence or challenge the reasoning.
Members can comment for free
Create a free membership or sign in.