“The article states that former President William Howard Taft weighed over 350 pounds.”
Attributed to The Daily Wire (reporting, quoting Trump's reading about the book)
While reading the book "Presidents Play!" the piece relays Trump's comment that Taft "weighed over 350 pounds" and was "our heaviest president."
What the proof shows
Contemporary reporting and a peer‑reviewed history-of-medicine paper (Deborah Levine, Annals of Internal Medicine) have been widely cited saying Taft was about 354 lb at his 1909 inauguration, which supports the Daily Wire’s phrasing that Taft “weighed over 350 pounds.” However, other historians and a medical researcher who examined Taft’s archived weight records (John G. Sotos, letter in Annals) and long‑standing biographies (e.g., Pringle) report lower peaks (about 335–340 lb) and note substantial day‑to‑day fluctuation. Primary archival records exist but have competing interpretations. So the claim is not clearly wrong, but it omits important context about varying sources, Taft’s weight fluctuations over time, and scholarly dispute over the exact peak figure.
Corrected version
Most reliable accounts say Taft was America’s heaviest president and his weight fluctuated widely; some archival research reports a peak of about 354 lb around his 1909 inauguration, while other historians who examined primary records place his peak closer to ~335–340 lb.
Automated evidence confidence: 0%
References and proof
Every link was reachable when published. Each proof point states how that source bears on the claim.
Corpulence and correspondence: President William H. Taft and the medical management of obesity ↗
Annals of Internal Medicine / PubMedDeborah I. Levine (Ann Intern Med. 2013) analyzes Taft’s correspondence with dietician N. E. Yorke‑Davies; Levine’s reporting has been summarized in news outlets as recording Taft at about 354 lb at his 1909 inauguration.
US President William Taft followed a weight loss program too (syndicated Reuters coverage) ↗
Reuters (syndicated via GMA News)Reporting on Levine's Annals paper: 'Despite his initial success... Taft weighed 354 pounds when he was inaugurated as president in 1909.'
William Howard Taft: Fat Jokes ↗
DoctorZebra (physician-run presidential health site)Summarizes sources and argues 'there is no record he ever weighed more than 340 pounds' and calls the 2013 Annals piece 'error-filled' on some numeric claims.
A Short History of Dietary Habits of U.S. Presidents ↗
Los Angeles Times (archival reporting)The article states 'William Howard Taft weighed 332 pounds at his inauguration.'
Discussion
Disagreement is welcome. Spam and abuse are not.
No published comments yet. Add evidence or challenge the reasoning.
Members can comment for free
Create a free membership or sign in.