“Israel attempted to kill Iran’s negotiators on their plane after talks between the U.S. and Iran in Pakistan.”
Attributed to The New York Times (as reported by the Daily Caller, citing anonymous U.S. officials)
Article says NYT, citing anonymous U.S. officials, reported an Israeli attempt to shoot down the Iranian diplomatic plane carrying negotiators after talks in Pakistan.
What the proof shows
The Daily Caller’s headline asserts as fact that “Israel attempted to kill Iran’s negotiators on their plane.” Reporting from multiple major outlets (citing a New York Times investigation based on anonymous U.S. officials) says U.S. officials privately feared Israel might be planning to target Iran’s lead negotiators during April talks and that Iran’s delegation took extraordinary security precautions; Iranian sources say the delegation’s flight was warned and diverted and was escorted by Pakistani jets. Those reports are intelligence-based and attributed to anonymous officials; Israel’s government has publicly denied the account. Public, independently verifiable proof of an Israeli attempt (e.g., an official Israeli admission, declassified intercepts, or an independent agency finding) has not been released. Therefore the Daily Caller’s wording turns an intelligence-based, partially corroborated report and denials/claims into an unequivocal factual claim that an Israeli attempt occurred — which overstates what is publicly provable now.
Corrected version
The New York Times reported that U.S. officials privately feared Israel might have been planning to target Iran’s negotiators during April talks; Iranian sources say their plane was warned and diverted and was escorted by Pakistani jets, while Israel denies the report.
Automated evidence confidence: 0%
References and proof
Every link was reachable when published. Each proof point states how that source bears on the claim.
Israel Reportedly Attempted To Shoot Down Iran’s Negotiators ↗
The Daily CallerIsrael attempted to kill Iran’s negotiators on their plane after talks between the U.S. and Iran concluded in Pakistan, The New York Times reported... Iran’s security forces notified the plane that two Israeli fighter jets had entered Iranian airspace with the intention of attacking it. However, the plane was not shot down as it made an emergency landing in Mashhad... the diplomatic jet also had an escort from Pakistani fighter jets.
Iran FM confirms reports Israel planned to target Tehran's negotiators ↗
Euronews (reporting, citing Iranian FM)Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi has confirmed media reports that officials in Washington believe Israel may have tried to kill Iran's top negotiators... Pakistani fighter jets escorted the Iranian delegation's aircraft from the Iranian border to Islamabad and back, and the Iranian aircraft made an emergency landing in Mashhad amid an alleged Israeli military threat.
The Intercept summary of NYT reporting (Rest of the World Report) ↗
Rest of the World Report (news summary referencing NYT)According to the New York Times... Ghalibaf was returning to Tehran from Islamabad... Pakistani fighter jets had escorted the Iranian delegation... Iranian security forces informed the aircraft that two Israeli fighter jets had entered Iranian airspace from the western border near Iraq and were preparing to attack. The plane made an emergency landing in Mashhad.
US-Iran War Daily Brief / aggregator note referencing Reuters: Israel removed two Iranian officials from its hit list after Pakistan intervened ↗
GlobalPolitics.in (aggregator citing Reuters)On 26 March, Reuters reported that Israel removed Iran's Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi and Parliamentary Speaker Mohammad Baqer Qalibaf from its hit list after Pakistan requested the United States to press Israel not to eliminate them.
Discussion
Disagreement is welcome. Spam and abuse are not.
No published comments yet. Add evidence or challenge the reasoning.
Members can comment for free
Create a free membership or sign in.