Fox & Watchdog
← Public evidence ledger
The Daily Caller
Article misinformation risk ★★☆☆☆ 2.1/5 Use caution · 3 checked claims
DC Exclusives - Original Reporting Enterprise Newsletter: Culture Wars Amazon book banning Censorship Mark Dice US

Conservative Writer Mark Dice Calls Out Media After Amazon Fails To Explain Why It Banned Popular Book

The article reports that Amazon temporarily removed conservative author Mark Dice’s 2023 book The War on Conservatives, later restored it after a Daily Caller inquiry and told the outlet the removal was “in error.” Dice disputes that explanation, says two appeals were denied with stated reasons, and says the book had become a top seller with thousands of ratings and reviews that were deleted and restored.

Open the original The Daily Caller article ↗

Accurate
Public importance 70/100

“After restoring Mark Dice’s book following a Daily Caller inquiry, Amazon told the Daily Caller that “this title was removed in error.””

Attributed to Amazon (as reported to the Daily Caller)

✓ Proof standard met 3 reachable references Independent-source requirement passed
Original context and attribution

The Daily Caller says Amazon restored Dice’s book and told the outlet the removal was an ‘‘error’’ after the Caller asked Amazon about the book’s delisting.

What the proof shows

The Daily Caller published direct reporting that an Amazon spokesperson told the Caller "this title was removed in error" after the listing was restored; the Amazon product page for the book is currently available, consistent with a restoration. I found the spokesperson quote only in the Daily Caller story (and republished copies) and did not find a separate Amazon press release providing additional explanation, but the publisher’s statement that Amazon told them the title was removed in error is supported by the cited reporting and the live Amazon listing.

Corrected version

An Amazon spokesperson told the Daily Caller (in articles published June 29–July 2, 2026) that "this title was removed in error" and the book’s Amazon listing was restored; the Amazon product page now shows the title available for sale.

Automated evidence confidence: 0%

References and proof

Every link was reachable when published. Each proof point states how that source bears on the claim.

Independent reporting Supports

Amazon Delists Conservative YouTuber’s Book Over Potentially ‘Disappointing Customer Experience,’ Then Claims ‘Error’ ↗

Daily Caller News Foundation
Proof point

An Amazon spokesperson told the Caller on Monday that "this title was removed in error and is now available for sale."

Independent reporting Supports

Conservative Writer Mark Dice Calls Out Media After Amazon Fails To Explain Why It Banned Popular Book ↗

Daily Caller
Proof point

After restoring Dice’s book, "The War on Conservatives," following a Daily Caller inquiry, Amazon told the Caller on Monday that "this title was removed in error."

Official data Supports

The War on Conservatives: Dice, Mark: 9781943591121: Amazon.com: Books ↗

Amazon.com
Proof point

The War on Conservatives by Mark Dice ... Publication date November 7, 2023 ... Ships from: Amazon.com Sold by: Amazon.com (product page indicates the listing is available).

Missing important context
Public importance 70/100

“Mark Dice’s book The War on Conservatives reached the No. 4 spot on Amazon’s overall best-seller list, and its thousands of positive ratings and hundreds of written reviews were deleted and then restored.”

Attributed to Mark Dice (as quoted by the Daily Caller)

✓ Proof standard met 4 reachable references Independent-source requirement passed
Original context and attribution

Dice told the Daily Caller the title had thousands of positive ratings, hundreds of written reviews that were deleted and later restored, and that it reached No. 4 on Amazon’s overall best-seller list.

What the proof shows

The claim rests primarily on Mark Dice’s own statements (reposted by the Daily Caller and other outlets) and on an Amazon reply reported to the Daily Caller that the listing was “removed in error” and later restored. I found Dice’s posts claiming the book hit #4 and that ratings/reviews were deleted and restored, and the Daily Caller/AOL articles reporting Amazon’s statement. I did not find independent Amazon records, a Best Sellers list snapshot, or a third‑party sales tracker capturing a historical Amazon overall #4 ranking or the exact counts of ratings/reviews removed and later restored; therefore the ranking and the precise magnitudes of deleted/restored reviews cannot be independently verified from available public records. The available sources support that Dice claimed those things and that Amazon (as reported) restored the listing, but do not confirm the No. 4 overall rank or the specific numbers of ratings/reviews.

Corrected version

Mark Dice and outlets reporting him say his book was briefly delisted by Amazon, that Amazon later said the removal was “an error” and restored the listing (and that Dice says thousands of ratings and hundreds of written reviews were deleted and later restored). I could not find independent Amazon bestseller snapshots or third‑party tracker data publicly confirming a No. 4 overall Amazon ranking or the exact numbers of deleted/restored reviews.

Automated evidence confidence: 0%

References and proof

Every link was reachable when published. Each proof point states how that source bears on the claim.

Independent reporting Supports

Conservative Writer Mark Dice Calls Out Media After Amazon Fails To Explain Why It Banned Popular Book ↗

The Daily Caller
Proof point

Dice said the book had 'garnered thousands of positive ratings and hundreds of written reviews ... and reached the No. 4 spot on the site’s overall best-seller list.'

Primary source Supports

Mark Dice Telegram Channel (post: book hit number 4 on Amazon) ↗

Mark Dice / Telegram (archived)
Proof point

In posts Mark Dice wrote that 'my new book The War on Conservatives hit number 4 on Amazon's bestseller list' on release.

Independent reporting Supports

Amazon Delists Conservative YouTuber’s Book Over Potentially ‘Disappointing Customer Experience,’ Then Claims ‘Error’ (republished) ↗

AOL (republishing Daily Caller reporting)
Proof point

An Amazon spokesperson told the Caller on Monday that 'this title was removed in error and is now available for sale.'

Official data Contradicts

The War on Conservatives by Mark Dice - Google Play Books ↗

Google Play / publisher listing
Proof point

Book listing confirming the existence and publication details of 'The War on Conservatives'.

Missing important context
Public importance 70/100

“Dice says Amazon denied two separate appeals: the first said the book violated Amazon’s content policies, and the second said the book “might result in a disappointing customer experience.””

Attributed to Mark Dice (as quoted by the Daily Caller)

✓ Proof standard met 4 reachable references Independent-source requirement passed
Original context and attribution

According to Dice’s account to the Daily Caller, his initial appeal was rejected on grounds of violating content policies and a later appeal was rejected as possibly causing a disappointing customer experience.

What the proof shows

The Daily Caller quotes Mark Dice and publishes screenshots (attributed to Dice) showing Amazon responses that Dice says denied his first appeal for violating “content policies” and denied a later executive appeal saying the title “might result in a disappointing customer experience.” Those documents (as reported) support that Dice made that claim and that Amazon communications with those phrases existed in Dice’s view. Amazon, however, told the Daily Caller the title was “removed in error” when contacted and did not confirm or detail the content of the appeal responses. Amazon’s KDP guidance shows the phrase “disappointing customer experience” is an established, broad category the platform uses; independent reporting and author community posts show Amazon often uses that wording generically. So Dice’s account is supported by his screenshots as published, but the publisher’s article omits independent confirmation from Amazon about the appeal texts and important context about how Amazon uses that wording.

Corrected version

Mark Dice says Amazon denied his initial appeal citing violations of its content policies and that a subsequent executive-level reply said the title “might result in a disappointing customer experience”; the Daily Caller published screenshots of those responses. Amazon told the Daily Caller the title was later “removed in error” and did not confirm the appeal-message wording.

Automated evidence confidence: 0%

References and proof

Every link was reachable when published. Each proof point states how that source bears on the claim.

Independent reporting Supports

Amazon Delists Conservative YouTuber’s Book Over Potentially ‘Disappointing Customer Experience,’ Then Claims ‘Error’ ↗

The Daily Caller
Proof point

Dice said that Amazon’s rejection of the first appeal claimed the book had violated the conglomerate’s “content policies,” while the second appeal suggested that the book “might result in a disappointing customer experience.”

Independent reporting Contradicts

Conservative Writer Mark Dice Calls Out Media After Amazon Fails To Explain Why It Banned Popular Book ↗

The Daily Caller
Proof point

After restoring Dice’s book ... Amazon told the Caller on Monday that “this title was removed in error.” The company has since declined to offer any additional context for how an error could account for ... the denial of two separate appeals.

Official data Contradicts

Guide to Kindle Content Quality ↗

Amazon KDP (Kindle Direct Publishing)
Proof point

We do not allow content that disappoints our customers or creates a poor shopping experience ... ‘Disappointing content’ — we do not allow content that disappoints our customers or creates a poor shopping experience.

Official data Contradicts

Content Guidelines ↗

Amazon KDP (Kindle Direct Publishing)
Proof point

If we remove a title, we let the author, publisher, or selling partner know and they can appeal our decision. ... Books for sale on Amazon should provide a positive customer experience.

COMMUNITY EVIDENCE

Discussion

Disagreement is welcome. Spam and abuse are not.

No published comments yet. Add evidence or challenge the reasoning.

Members can comment for free

Create a free membership or sign in.